
We would argue the relevance of Hannah Ardent. Actually, he would argue the relevance. I would argue the necessity of it in his Intro to Philos class, and his inability to teach it.
That class began with 47 students. There were 8 of us left by the final. He said, that was "par for his course.'
He would talk in circles about something historic. We would wait for the connection that never came. He would assign texts and we would buy them and read them. Then he would give us a test: not on the historic circular speeches, and not on the texts assigned. The test would be on a philosopher we hadn’t discussed. When this was pointed out, he’d simply say, “I can’t teach philosophy on a timeline.” Delete the last three Words, and you get to the truth.
He was the kind of professor that made you hate a major you loved. He’d sour your taste for something you had craved. You left that class emptier, having lost something you didn’t think anyone could take away.
He had a little silver ponytail, and the obligatory round framed glasses and corduroy blazer. On our first date he told me he had me all figured out. He was smug as he told a sharpened tale of how I must have married young and was now divorced at 27, and on my own for the first time. It went on from there and included wealthy suburban parents that coddled me. When I told him I’d never been married, left home at 17, mother was an alcoholic, father was a cheating sociopath, and that I grew up dirt poor in a small apartment in Brooklyn, he actually said, “Are you sure?” Because, you know, he couldn’t actually be wrong, could he?
He called me “sweet meat” and insinuated that I didn’t deserve the grade he was giving me. I pointed out that was more of an insult to him that it was to me.

She was a photographer. We worked at the same offbeat professional photo lab for about 8 months. We’d meet in the dark room and make out. She couldn’t wait to introduce me to her parents and her sister, who seemed to disbelieve everything. She had been hurt by an ex who scared me. She ended it when she decided I wasn’t going to fall in love with her. And she was right. But I liked her a lot. Much more than she realized, and I still carry it: a respect that I don’t offer easily. I’m sure it would surprise her how often I think of her, how fondly I remember. She taught me a certain sensitivity. She read The Growing Tree to me. And the last time we spoke she said she was tired.

He was younger than I was, and I was pretty young. He worked in a bookstore and listened to Depeche Mode. He was thoughtful, and gentle, and new. Our friends didn’t mesh, our futures didn’t align. I was always honest about what I was feeling. He got in too deep, and I will always respect him for that. He refused to know it wasn’t going to work until it didn’t. I hate that he remembers the break up, not the experience, first and foremost. But you can’t win them all. I wish there’d been a better way, to have known him for that month without hurting him for longer.
There is always a better way.And every one was meant to matter.
.